Find the most up-to-date information about City facility availability, services and programs on the COVID-19 page.

Westerville's Most Wanted

Press Enter to show all options, press Tab go to next option

If you recognize or have seen any of the people listed below, please contact (614) 882-7444. The Westerville Division of Police encourages you not to approach these individuals as they could be dangerous.

Wanted: Information Sought in Ongoing Sexual Abuse Investigation

The Westerville Division of Police (WPD), in cooperation with the Delaware County Prosecutor’s Office and Delaware County Sheriff’s Office, is seeking information on Gary Michael Hill of Plain City, Ohio (pictured below) in an ongoing sexual abuse case involving at least five minors. Hill is most commonly known as “Michael” or “Mike.”

Investigators are releasing this information because they believe there may be more victims in Central Ohio. 

A Delaware County Grand Jury returned a 14-count indictment against Hill in January 2018 that alleges a series of criminal acts from June 1, 2001 through December 30, 2017.  Find more information in the full news release from WPD

Image of Gary Michael Hill of Plain City

Wanted: Robbery

The Westerville Division of Police (WPD) is seeking information on a suspect (pictured below) related to a robbery on January 16, 2019 at the CVS Pharmacy located at the intersection of S. Cleveland Ave./W. Schrock Rd. in Westerville. 
• The suspect is described as male; approximately 5'06", 130-150 lbs.
• He was wearing a green jacket, black hoodie, black or dark blue track pants, slip-on sandals and carrying a backpack.

Anyone with information on the identity of this man is asked to contact the WPD Tipline at (614) 901-6866 or email
Image for NR 19-001

Wanted: Theft

The Westerville Division of Police (WPD) is seeking information on the suspect pictured here from surveillance video of a theft from Gold Star Jewelry (592 W. Shrock Rd.) on Tuesday, November 27. The suspect is shown distracting the store clerk and then stealing a Cartier watch valued at more than $6,000. 

Anyone with information on the individual pictured on the screenshot or video ( is asked to contact the Investigative Tipline at (614) 901-6866 or
Image for WPD NR 18-019

Wanted: Theft

The Westerville Division of Police needs your help identifying these two individuals. On July 19, the suspects pictured attempted to use stolen credit cards at the Polaris Fashion Place Apple and Von Maur stores.  If you have any information to assist police, please contact our anonymous tip line at (614) 901-6866 or Review the Crime Alert flier.

 WPD investigation Oct 2018

Most Wanted Archives:

2011- 2015




Free viewers are required for some of the attached documents.
They can be downloaded by clicking on the icons below.

Acrobat Reader Download Acrobat Reader Flash Player Download Flash Player Windows Media Player Download Windows Media Player Microsoft Silverlight Download Microsoft Silverlight Word Viewer Download Word Viewer Excel Viewer Download Excel Viewer PowerPoint Viewer Download PowerPoint Viewer